By England’s Champions Trophy 2025 defeat to Afghanistan was marred by poor shot selection and questionable player decisions. Here are some crucial points that emphasize these issues:
Poor shot selection.
* Critical Moments: England’s batsmen, particularly Harry Brook and Jos Buttler, made promising starts but were unable to convert them into significant scores. Afghanistan’s defeat was largely due to their inability to maintain partnership under pressure. The expulsion of Joe Root swung the trend in their favor. Later, Jamie Overton’s wild shot to long-on proved costly, giving Afghanistan the opportunity to finish out the game.
Questionable player selection.
* Injury Impact: England had to replace injured pacer Brydon Carse with spinner Rehan Ahmed in their roster, but for this match, they chose Jamie Overton over Ahmed. The spin-friendly conditions may have hampered England’s bowling tactics. Additionally, despite having a quality batting lineup, they struggled to form regular partnerships. They had in squad eight bowlers, four specialised batters and only one all rounder.
The inconsistency of Phil Salt and Harry Brook, combined with their susceptibility to spin, was a major problem that Afghanistan successfully exploited.
Afghanistan achieved a tough total of 325/7, with Ibrahim Zadran scoring 177 and Hashmatullah Shahidi and Azmatullah Omarzai making major contributions. Zadran’s collaboration with Shahidi, and later with Omarzai, was critical in establishing a competitive benchmark7.
* England’s Response: England needed 326 runs but only scored 317. Despite a good start by Joe Root and Ben Duckett, they could not maintain the momentum throughout the innings.
Overall, England’s failure to capitalize on promising starts, as well as their weakness in Afghanistan’s spin attack, contributed significantly to their defeat. Furthermore, the team’s selection decisions, especially in response to injuries, could have influenced the outcome
Hindi
Tamil
Telugu